Hiding in the Binding — Fragments in Rare Book Collections at HMML

December 8, 2022
Hiding in the Binding — Fragments in Rare Book Collections at HMML

This story is part of an ongoing series of editorials in which HMML curators and catalogers examine how specific themes appear across HMML’s digital collections. From the Special Collections, Dr. Matthew Z. Heintzelman shares this story about Fragments.


Much of human history remains for us today only in the form of smaller remnants or fragments of larger works. Such bits and pieces sometimes provide important insights into the cultures we come from. The Oxford English Dictionary defines a fragment as “a part broken off or otherwise detached from a whole; a broken piece; a (comparatively) small, detached portion of anything.”

Over the past several years, interest in fragments has developed into a specialized area of manuscript studies called fragmentology, which even has its own dedicated journal (Fragmentology). In manuscript collections, a fragment is often thought of as a physical remnant of a manuscript that was once “whole.” But a text that is incomplete can also be considered a fragment of the whole text, even if the vessel itself (e.g., the book) is physically intact. Manuscript or book collections, too, can be fragmented and dispersed across different locations or among different owners.

SJRB 00157
This fragment, written in Hebrew, was probably used as a book cover at some point. It is now part of the Saint John’s University Rare Book and Manuscript collection. (SJRB 00157)
SJRB 00157
The fragment exhibits the heavy use of glue on one side, leading to the loss of much of the text. (SJRB 00157)

HMML has photographed hundreds of thousands of manuscript fragments since its first library partnerships in 1965.

In the collections of HMML, the Malta Study Center, and Saint John’s University—all located at HMML in Collegeville, Minnesota—there are more than 100 manuscript fragments (and many more printed fragments), most of which are now viewable in HMML Reading Room. Their diversity makes them extremely useful for teaching about manuscripts, languages, and scripts. The materials are chiefly in Latin, but also include many items in Arabic, Coptic, Ethiopic, Persian, German, Hebrew, Dutch, Armenian, and Syriac. Some have musical notation or marginal glosses. They range in size from about 3.5 inches (9 cm) tall to more than 30 inches (76 cm) tall. The oldest is about 1,500 years old, while the newest might be from the 18th century. Some are drab and others are stunningly beautiful. And several remain hidden in the bindings of other manuscripts or printed books!

Pieces of parchment manuscript help hold together a printed book
Pieces of parchment manuscript help hold together a printed book. (Saint John’s University Rare Book and Manuscript collection, uncataloged)

Becoming a Fragment

Manuscripts can become fragmented for many reasons. The most common means is through decay and destruction—for example, due to war, fire, water, aging, neglect, etc. A contributing factor can be when the material from which a manuscript is made is itself fragile or contains inks or adhesives that are corrosive.

Sometimes manuscripts fall prey to people who wish to isolate the prettiest parts, and thus they excise or cut out the beautiful miniatures and illuminated or elaborately decorated initials.

HMML 00006
This miniature is part of a set of two clippings containing four miniatures, taken from a 13th-century copy of the Book of Revelation (or Apocalypse). (HMML 00006)
AARB 00064
An initial has been excised (or cut out) from this page of a late-medieval missal. (AARB 00064)

Some modern dealers of rare materials have engaged in the practice of “breaking” books—cutting out the pages and selling or distributing them separately. The most famous of these book-breakers was Otto Ege (1888–1951), but there have been many others. Several manuscript fragments in the Arca Artium collection come from broken books.

AARB 00073
This bifolium—a sheet folded to create two connected leaves—is from a 14th-century breviary. The beautiful decoration likely prompted a book dealer to separate the leaves of the manuscript for sale individually. (AARB 00073)

However, one could argue that the greatest loss of manuscripts has been through the reuse or “recycling” of old leaves, especially ones made of durable parchment. This usually happened when the contents of the manuscript were no longer current or were not of interest to later audiences. The reusing of leaves took many forms:

HMML 00076
An early modern notarial journal that uses a fragment—late medieval music—as a book cover. The contents of the manuscript are in no way related to the music on the cover. (HMML 00076)

What follows is a gallery of fragments that have been recycled through the centuries, to show some of the ways that bits and pieces of manuscripts now appear in HMML’s Special Collections.

Book covers

One of the most common ways to reuse parchment leaves is as the actual cover of another book.

AARB 00040
A large 19th-century compilation of musical chant, wrapped in a parchment manuscript cover. This image has been rotated to show the manuscript better. (AARB 00040)
SJRB 00126
This fragment was used as a book cover; the fold for the spine is visible midway down the page. The header on the manuscript leaf identifies it as a text by Cicero (“Ciceronis,” or “of Cicero”), but the attribution cannot be verified and is likely erroneous. (SJRB 00126)
SJRB 00126
The reverse of the Cicero page was dyed green and had decoration pressed in, obliterating most of the text on that side. (SJRB 00126)

Pastedowns

A pastedown is the sheet glued into the front and/or back cover of a book; it helps to hide the elements that hold the book together. If one uses a strong material like parchment, the pastedown can also provide further stability to the binding.

SJRB 00124
Introits from Mass, along with musical notation. This fragment was almost certainly reused as a pastedown in a book. The crenellations along the top were likely cut out to accommodate the bands or cords on the spine. (SJRB 00124)
HMML 00002
This pastedown has come loose, so behind it one can see the hidden mechanics of the book binding. The pastedown itself is a medieval legal document, written in German (text partially cut off on the right edge). (HMML 00002)
HMML 00002
Behind the pastedown are the hidden mechanics of the book binding, including the ends of the leather cords onto which the leaves have been bound. (HMML 00002)

Flyleaves

Flyleaves are used at the front and back of a book to protect the main text and to make the binding stronger. In the era of hand-bound books, they were often recycled from parchment manuscripts.

parchment leaves used as flyleaves in a printed book
An example of parchment leaves used as flyleaves in a printed book. A dutiful librarian at Saint John’s even glued a slip for stamping circulation dates onto the manuscript “waste.” (Saint John’s University Rare Book and Manuscript collection, uncataloged)

Folded Pieces to Reinforce Gatherings or Quires

Often, parchment manuscripts were cut into little strips or stubs to provide strength, especially when binding paper pages. If these are still in the book, they may only appear as small stubs along the gutter of the page openings; should they be removed from the binding, their previous use can be identified by the crease passing anomalously through the text. In other cases, such strips of parchment may be glued into the back of a book to strengthen the gatherings along the spine.

AARB 00199
The collector who formed Arca Artium, Frank Kacmarcik, had one of his printed books re-bound. In the process, the binder removed numerous fragments with beautiful script from the binding, which today are preserved under one shelf mark. (AARB 00199)
AARB 00199
A closer view shows a vertical crease caused by the fragment’s service as a stub in the book’s gutter. (AARB 00199)
AARB 00233 +1
A 9th-century fragment containing a commentary on the Gospel of John written in Caroline minuscule. (AARB 00233)
Deteriorating leather along the spine

Other Examples: Palimpsests, Repairs, and…a Lampshade (?)

Due to its durability, parchment will often outlive the usefulness of its contents. Sometimes, later generations have simply washed or scraped off the old ink (and text) and written a new text over it. Sometimes, a more valued manuscript is held together with pieces of a manuscript that is no longer wanted. And sometimes, the manuscript comes back in a completely different form that might surprise us.

SJRB 00162
This manuscript contains liturgical texts, probably dating from the 18th or 19th centuries. However, one can see that there is a different layer of text (probably also liturgical) peeking out of the page. The lighter spot in the upper left corner is from a fancier initial that has been mostly scraped off. (SJRB 00162)
SJRB 00003
This antiphonary was apparently very important to the religious community that once owned it. After much use (and turning of pages), several leaves required repairs along their bottom edges. (SJRB 00003)
SJRB 00003 +2
At the bottom of several leaves, pieces of parchment have been sewn on to repair and extend the use of the manuscript. (SJRB 00003)
SJRB 00532 SJRB 00532

Want to see more manuscript fragments from the collections that HMML has photographed and cataloged? Go to HMML Reading Room and select “Fragments” from the “Genre/Form(s)” field in Advanced Search.

Oh, yes, and if you have clues that could help describe the fragments’ histories, please send us your suggestions!

Share: 

Get the latest news direct to your inbox

You can unsubscribe at any time.